Letters to the editor
Petworth dealers bite back
in response to the article in 6 August ATG headed “Tides turning as Gardner Exits?” A Petworth dealer – Jane Walton- responds as follows:-
The ATG and David Moss, recently published an article/advert (depending on your opinion) entitled “Tides turning as Gardner exits?’
It promotes a dealer who is leaving Petworth who chooses to lay much blame for his lack of business on the town itself – always an easy option. I have my own opinions on why such an article was written and I give credit to those who have read it and know Petworth, to see it for what it is, a biased, unfair and untrue account.
I am saddened that the ATG, which is meant to support and champion our industry, especially in these challenging times, has allowed itself to be used in a way that allows Mr Gardner to promote his business at the expense of the rest of us in Petworth; some of whom he has known for many years. The “article” does not seek to offer an alternative view, or to look deeper and see if what was being written was true. The editor does not seem to understand why I and others find the article offensive, but he suggested I write this letter and he promised to print it, presumably by way of addressing the balance.
Petworth is not the holy Grail, but it has a very good reputation, and a diverse and large number of dealers. We have been accused of many things by Mr Gardner, that we don’t advertise, that we ride on the back of Petworth’s old reputation, that we don’t attract new clients. When I am here to tell Mr Gardner that you don’t speak for me, nor draw a true picture of my business with your comments.
With a publication such as the ATG, with a circulation they would have us believe is fast and read throughout the world, comes a responsibility. A responsibility to encourage, nurture, and promote and write fairly about the industry they represent and the people in it.
This one-sided article has caused much distress in Petworth, not because Mr Gardner is leaving, but because both he and the ATG had insinuated throughout the article that Petworth has had its day. The suggestion is that the town is no longer a viable option for anyone to trade from. It ignores the fact that new businesses, including Kiki design, have opened here. As many towns go through a period of change, this often regenerates it and keeps it interesting.
That it no longer lives up to Mr Gardner’s expectations is unfortunate, but as I said to him, it has also earned him a very good living for a good number of years.
The letter is written by Jane Walton and kindly supported by Vicki Emery (Antiquated), Patrick Howgill (Alexis antique)s, George Perez-Martin (Brownrigg), Sarah Hughes (Phoenix antiques), Sarah and John (Kiki design) and Elizabeth (Tudor Rose antiques).



















